CASE PRESENTATION EVALUATION FORM
     
    CASE ________________________ TEAM ___________
     
    Excellent + Acceptable Poor -
     
    I. Organization and Presentation of Report
    10pt A. Legibility
    B. Length of report
    C. Organization of report
    D. Spelling and use of grammar
    E. Effectiveness of writing style
    F. Use of references and exhibits
    II. Contents of Report
    A. Situational definition
    20pts 1. Considered current performance, mission,
    objectives, etc.
    2. Considered strategic managers
    3. Dealt with societal trends
    4. Dealt with industry opportunities and threats
    5. Identified internal strengths
    6. Identified internal weaknesses
    7. Stated strategic factors clearly and concisely
    8. considered both immediate and long term problems
    B. Situation Analysis
    20pts 1. Distinguished between symptoms and underlying
    problems or causes
    2. Distinguished between facts, opinion, and own
    inferences
    3. recognized all important factors
    4. Considered the time frame of the case
    5. Avoided excessive rehash of case facts
    6. Reflected good understanding of case material
    7. Brought in outside information as appropriate
    8. Utilized relevant concepts in policy to aid
    understanding
    C. Alternative Assessment
    20pts 1. Identified all feasible alternatives
    2. Alternatives consistent with situation assessment
    3. Evaluated each alternative in terms of risk, cost,
    timing, etc. as pros and cons
    D. Recommendation
    20pts 1. Clearly presented the recommended solution
    2. Recommendation followed logically from previous
    analysis
    3. Provided for implementation of recommended solution,
    including priorities and control procedures
    E. Maintained proper balance among situation definition and
    10pts analysis, alternative assessment, and recommendation
    III. Overall Evaluation
    COMMENTS
    STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES
     
    6

    Back to top